You've found a retirement village you love and chosen your villa, but your house hasn't sold and the money you were counting on hasn't arrived. In her latest NZ Herald column, Age Brightly founder Hannah McQueen explains that this is a problem you can often work through, because the sale price of your home is only one of several things you can change. Read the full article in the NZ Herald.
Here's a recap of the ideas we think are most useful if you, or a parent, are in this position.
Why village living appeals, and what you're really buying
Retirement villages aren't for everyone, but Hannah notes the appeal is easy to understand. A village supports independent living, which is different from residential care. She also points to an Australian Retirement Living Council report, Better Housing for Better Health, which found hospitalisations fell by almost 20% in the nine months after residents moved in. Residents were also more physically active, happier and up to five times more socially engaged.
The first thing to understand is what you're paying for. In most villages you don't own the villa. You pay a lump sum for the right to live there under an Occupation Right Agreement (ORA), and when you leave, the village keeps part of that payment through a Deferred Management Fee (DMF). Hannah's example:
-
You pay $800,000 upfront for a villa, with a DMF capped at 30 per cent.
-
When you leave, $560,000 is returned to you or your estate and the village keeps $240,000.
-
Over 10 years, that works out at about $24,000 a year, or roughly $461 a week.
That's before counting the return you give up on the $800,000 and any weekly village fees. Retirement village prices also tend not to fall when house prices do, because operators have development costs to recover. That means the negotiation looks different from a normal house purchase.
Four levers, not one
Most people fixate on the sale price of their home. Hannah's point is that there are four levers, and they work together:
-
The price you accept for your home. Say you expected $1.1 million, but the best realistic offer is $900,000. Hannah suggests first asking whether the original number was ever realistic, and whether your agent's strategy, marketing and pricing advice is doing the job. Selling is one of the biggest transactions you'll make, so it's not the time to give a novice a go.
-
The villa you choose. A cheaper villa can make up some of the shortfall.
-
The financial terms you negotiate with the village. Operators may be reluctant to cut the headline price, but many have flexibility elsewhere. They might accept a lower upfront payment in exchange for a higher deferred fee, offer a move-in incentive, waive weekly fees, contribute to moving costs or offer a cheaper villa.
-
Your investment and estate plan. The money left over still needs to be invested, and your estate plan adjusted to match.
In practice, you might accept $100,000 less for your home but negotiate a cheaper villa, a lower upfront payment or a break from weekly fees. Hannah is honest that coordinating all of this is tricky, and that none of the concessions is free money: a lower upfront payment in exchange for a higher DMF means less comes back when you leave. But knowing you have options can make a move possible when the original numbers no longer work, and may leave you better placed than waiting for a price the market won't deliver, or being forced to sell during a health crisis.
Know when to walk away
There's a difference between making the numbers work and forcing them to work. Before you commit, Hannah suggests understanding what happens if your health declines, you need residential care sooner than expected, or your estate has to wait for repayment. Specifically, check:
-
when the DMF stops accruing
-
whether weekly fees continue after you leave
-
who pays refurbishment costs
-
when your money is returned
Keep accessible savings too. The last thing you want is to move into your dream village and find you've used every available dollar to get there. And get independent legal advice on the agreement, plus financial and life-planning advice on retirement income and future care options. The house you're selling, the village you're entering and the money you'll have left are all part of the same equation.
Three tips if your house won't sell
-
Consider bridging finance, carefully. It can help you move before your house sells, but interest costs build up and a delayed sale can get expensive. It solves a timing problem, not an unrealistic asking price.
-
Don't be afraid to change real estate agents. It's awkward, but sometimes necessary. Check your agency agreement, then find someone who can deliver.
-
Change your strategy when the first approach doesn't land. If you're not getting the price you wanted, remember there are several levers to pull, each affecting the outcome differently. Get good advice from someone who can see the whole picture.
Sometimes the smartest move isn't holding out for the price you wanted. It's negotiating your way into the life you want, without putting your financial future at risk.
Want the full story? Read Hannah's column, Your house won't sell, but you've found your dream retirement village. Now what?, in the NZ Herald.
Thinking about how to stay independent for longer? Brightly's Baseline+ gives you a clear picture of where your health stands today. Book your Baseline+.
Hannah McQueen is the founder and director of Age Brightly and host of The Next Bit podcast.