Guides & Articles | Age Brightly

[The Next Bit Pod Recap] 20,000 Beds Short and a Plan to Fix It with Hon David Cunliffe

Written by Brightly | Nov 17, 2026, 7:44:16 AM

New Zealand's aged care system is, in the words of Hon David Cunliffe, "basically broken", with no way of coping with the wall of ageing New Zealanders arriving over the next 30 years. Cunliffe is a former Minister of Health who chaired the Ministerial Advisory Group (MAG) on aged care. In this episode he joins host Hannah McQueen to unpack the MAG's report: its 40 recommendations, the numbers behind them, and what they could mean for families.

His headline claim is that the plan could deliver better health outcomes for older New Zealanders and save close to a billion dollars a year compared with doing nothing. All figures below are as Cunliffe described them in conversation, and several are rounded or illustrative.

The problem: 20,000 beds short by 2047

New Zealand will be 20,000 residential care beds short by 2047. When someone can't get a rest home bed and can't stay at home, they stay in hospital, at about $2,000 a night.

That is why the cost curve is so steep. Aged care costs about $2.5 billion a year today. If we simply keep funding the same system for volume growth, Cunliffe says that nearly doubles to $4.6 billion a year in today's dollars.

The supply side is part of the problem. Nobody has built a new rest home bed in the last three to five years because the economics don't stack up, and a number of straight-out rest home providers have already left the market. As Cunliffe puts it, "It won't be corridor care. It'll be campground care."

Why the system is a one-way street

Most people end up in a rest home because of a hospital event, not a decision. Only about 30% of people who enter a rest home show a gradual, predictable decline. For the other 70%, something unplanned happens, most often a fall and a fracture, and they go from hospital straight into residential care.

Once you've had that hospital event, you are 10 times more likely to have the rest home event, and close to 50% of us end up dying in a rest home. Cunliffe calls it "almost a one-way system": home care, residential care and hospital care are separate silos, and home care services aren't at the level needed to get people back out again.

 

The pressure shows up in emergency departments too. Cunliffe says about three-quarters of people turning up to ED are over 65, often because they aren't getting enough care at home or can't get to a GP. Even the entry point is clogged, with an independent needs assessment currently backed up by about a year.

What "integrated care" means in practice

The report proposes a single regulatory framework, a single definition of a patient's care needs, and government-funded navigators to help older New Zealanders and their whānau find the right path. The aim is a two-way street, where people can move up and down the system as their needs change.

For someone like a 95-year-old grandad, Cunliffe says that means:

  • More primary and supportive care at home, with enough skill available to manage things like a catheter or a bag, so he can stay with his loved ones for longer.

  • Navigation support for him and his family when a move into residential care becomes likely.

  • Rehabilitation and respite, so a fall isn't automatically a one-way trip. Cunliffe's own mother spent three months in hospital after falling down stairs, then lived for years, returning to her flat and later a retirement village.

Respite is the weak link today. Hannah described a client who faced a two-year wait for a respite bed and could only get three days when she did. Providers lose money on respite because it costs to check someone in, supervise them while their stability is unknown, and discharge them. The report wants the Crown to cover that cost so providers are happy to offer it.

Making new beds worth building

The government currently pays a provider roughly $100,000 a year per bed (Cunliffe's Auckland ballpark), based on a bed-night rate. A "bed" here means the room, usually with an en suite, plus a share of the building's common space. That payment can cover the nurses, food and laundry for a good operator, but not a return on the capital spent, so when a building depreciates there's no money to renew it and the facility closes.

The report's answer is differentiated pricing: every provider is paid more, but new beds, which tend to be bigger rooms, get a bigger uplift than older, smaller, heavily depreciated ones. As an illustration, on a base of 100, new beds would rise to about 126 over two years including inflation, and older beds to about 112. The principle is that a dollar invested anywhere in the sector should earn a similar return, which Cunliffe put at about 6.6% after inflation.

Paying the same uplift to everyone, he argues, would hand windfall gains to old facilities and still wouldn't get new ones built. He stressed the numbers are estimates and may be refined with more industry data, but the principle is what matters.

The numbers: invest $168 million, save $835 million

Cunliffe says the plan needs roughly $168 million more a year (modelled on a 2037 steady state, in today's dollars) to build up home care and fund new beds. After paying for that, the net saving to the system is $835 million a year. Spending on aged care would rise from about $2.5 billion today to $3.7 billion, instead of $4.6 billion if nothing changes.

The biggest savings come from keeping people well at home. As a rule of thumb, one night in hospital costs the same as one month of supported care at home, or about one week in residential care.

Cunliffe broke the $835 million down with a pizza analogy:

Source of saving

Approx. share

Co-payment changes

About half

More efficient funding (differentiated bed pricing)

About a quarter

Integrated system that keeps people out of hospital

About a quarter

Hannah pushed back that $168 million spread across all beds looks small. Cunliffe noted the figure is gross of the increased co-payments, about $495 million, which go into the residential care pot.

Who pays: a curve instead of a cliff

The biggest change for families is how co-payments work. Today residential care is a cliff: the state pays everything until your assets pass about $297,000, and then you pay the lot, roughly $100,000 a year. (Cunliffe said the threshold is lower, "190-something", if you choose to have the family home exempt.) The report proposes a curve, and for the first time, modest co-payments for home care.

 

Today

Proposed

Residential care contribution

Nothing below about $297,000 in assets, then the full cost

Starts at $100,000 in assets, rises in a straight line, tops out at $350,000

Cap on payments

None

Five-year lifetime maximum

Home care

No co-payment

Community Services Card income pays nothing; up to double that income, up to a quarter of care costs; above that, up to half; never more than half

Clinical care

Inconsistent: free in public hospitals and at home, not in residential care

Free wherever you receive it (about a third of total care cost)

Cunliffe says more people are drawn into the net, but most at lower levels than today, and the five-year cap protects families facing dementia or other long-term conditions from losing every asset. The home care co-payment would bring in only about $34 million a year nationwide, and he argues paying something encourages people to take a close interest in what they're getting.

The family home exemption stays, because a spouse still at home shouldn't be forced out, but the report proposes a cap on the home's value to stop what Cunliffe calls the "mansion effect" of shifting assets into a very large house. He floated $3 million as an illustration only; the report names no figure. Hannah noted most New Zealanders hold wealth in their homes rather than cash, and Cunliffe agreed people will need to draw on that equity, for example through a reverse mortgage.

 

His fairness argument is about the next generation. Today there are about four taxpayers for every person receiving superannuation, and by 2070 there will be about two. The report also recommends a save-as-you-go long-term aged care savings fund, and Cunliffe says superannuation needs its own honest conversation.

Home care: assessments, contracts and carers

Assessments. To access home care you need a needs assessment from NASC. The people are highly qualified, but there aren't enough of them and the wait can be a year, sometimes 18 months. The report proposes that NASC handles the complex cases and acts as supervisor and auditor, while trained and audited frontline providers do the simple ones. Cunliffe's target is an assessor within a month.

Contracts. Health New Zealand is moving the country to a bulk-funded model, which Cunliffe says is about 30% cheaper than fee for service. His concern is the terms: 10-year contracts with huge catchments, such as one for all of Auckland, shut down competition and serve rural and ethnic communities poorly. The report recommends three-year terms, smaller catchments and agreed carve-outs, for example a community aged care centre in Wairoa offering both residential and home care, or a retirement village providing home care to its own independent units.

Carers. Carers are often paid largely through mileage, with about $250 million a year spent on travel between clients. Cunliffe's neighbour Hugh, 92, lives independently near Leigh and needs four hours of support a week; his carer drives 100 kilometres for two hours. The report proposes a working group of unions, providers and government to move toward higher pay for higher qualifications, and to upgrade carers toward "quasi-nursing" support.

For Hugh, the change would be an assessment within a month, the extra care, and potentially two more years at home. Cunliffe's shorthand for the upgraded service is "Home Care Plus".

Prevention and health intelligence

Hannah's lens as the founder of Age Brightly was that the system collects too little of the right data to spot decline before it happens. If 70% of hospital events for older people are a surprise, and most are preventable, you need data points to track risk and intervene early.

Cunliffe agreed. Data is getting cheaper and easier to gather, and many types of decline, such as congestive heart failure, dementia and diabetes, are fairly predictable with good early warning signs. Hannah described how much human time it still takes: about an hour of the person's time and another hour and a half of a clinician's, reviewing bloods, medications and comorbidities.

He likened the health system to a bathtub: people getting sick and entering hospital through ED are the taps, and people getting well are the plughole. To stop it overflowing, turn down the taps by investing upstream in primary and preventive care. Both agreed that a reactive primary care model, where you need a symptom to see a GP, can't deliver prevention in a 10-minute appointment, and that GPs are stretched, with unpaid ACC paperwork one example Cunliffe raised.

Cross-party support and what happens next

Cunliffe is proudest that all 10 MAG members, who represent different parts of the industry, signed up to every one of the 40 recommendations, with no abstentions. The Ministry of Health produced more than 100 advice papers and modelling support, and Cunliffe, a former Labour minister, chaired the group for a National and New Zealand First government on condition he could consult the lead opposition party along the way.

He says every party in Parliament, from the Māori Party and the Greens to ACT and New Zealand First, has expressed support for the direction of the report. He reports that Minister Costello has said publicly that the Ministry of Health has been asked for advice so an incoming government can take the work forward, including preparing for Budget 2027, and that Labour's health spokesperson Dr Ayesha Verrall and finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds support the direction and fiscal approach respectively. His message to any incoming government is to treat the report as a package and not cherry-pick.

The first three things he'd want done in the next 12 months:

  1. Set up implementation working groups with industry and health sector representation, ideally with some continuity from the MAG.

  2. Tell officials the work belongs in Budget 2027. The paperwork typically closes in March, so the first quarter will be busy.

  3. Scope out what 21st-century home care looks like ("Home Care Plus"), and drop 10-year contracts with massive catchments.

In 10 years, success looks like EDs no longer clogged with corridor care for the elderly, 20,000 more beds built by 2047, a far better qualified home care workforce, a higher share of the budget delivered at home, and people entering residential or hospital care later.

The takeaway

As Hannah puts it, we're finally being asked to confront the true scale of the aged care problem, including the uncomfortable question of how we pay for it. But there's an enormous opportunity too. If we get better at spotting health risks early, intervening before people deteriorate and supporting families before crisis point, we can improve quality of life while easing pressure on hospitals and residential care. The challenge now is improving what works, funding it properly, and making sure someone is accountable for delivering it, so New Zealanders get more good years, and help when they need it.

Listen to the full episode of The Next Bit, share it with someone who might find it useful, and subscribe for more conversations about navigating this stage of life. The Next Bit is proudly sponsored by Age Brightly.